Your trusted source for the latest news and insights on Markets, Economy, Companies, Money, and Personal Finance.

Gaining at the Cost of Pain: 2 Stocks Whose CEOs Abandoned Without Warning

Key Points

  • Planet Fitness removed its CEO of 30 years, causing shares to collapse over 30% in the following days.
  • Square’s new CEO abruptly left her position just eight months after becoming CEO.
  • A new CEO with a strong pedigree announcement can put bottoms in both stocks and replenish sentiment as a new beginning with a clean slate.
  • 5 stocks we like better than Planet Fitness

There has been a litany of CEO removals in the past year. Some of the headliners include the removal of The Walt Disney Co. (NYSE: DIS) CEO Bob Chapek in November 2022. The abrupt resignation of Discover Financial Services Inc. (NYSE: DFS) CEO Roger Hochschild in August 2023 shocked investors. More recently, two companies have reported abrupt removal or resignations of their CEOs with a tenure of 30 years and eight months, respectively.

Consequentially, the underlying stocks of these companies collapsed upon the news and continued to sell off from the uncertainty these actions created. Investors are left to ponder if these events are harbingers of devastating news to come. In selling off, value investors may start kicking the tires as the market may have overreacted, as it tends to do.

Both stocks have extremely oversold momentum readings, implying short-term pain for potential gain on the rebound.

Planet Fitness is a no-frills national gym chain with over 2,400 locations and over 18.1 million members in the United States. Memberships are as low as $10 per month with no contracts. Most gyms are also owned and operated by franchisees, making it an asset-light company. The company plans to grow its locations to over 4,000 gyms.

Business as Usual

On Aug. 13, 2023, the company reported Q2 2023 earnings of 65 per share, beating analyst estimates by 10 cents. Revenues grew 27.7% YoY to $286.5 million, beating estimates for $252 million. Guidance was mixed for full-year 2023, EPS is expected to rise around 34% to $2.20 versus $2.16 consensus analyst estimates. Revenues are expected to rise 12% YoY to $1.05 billion, matching estimates.

Unexpected Removal of CEO of 30 Years

On Sept. 13, 2023, the Board of Directors for Planet Fitness removed its CEO of 30 years, Chris Rondeau, with no explanation. Board Member Craig Benson replaces him as Interim CEO as the company searches for a new permanent CEO through a leading search firm. This sent shares collapsing 16% the following day as it lost more than 30% in the following days. The abrupt removal was especially worrisome since the Board didn’t yet have a permanent replacement, which implies urgency in his removal.

Abrupt Removals Spawn Suspicions

At Disney, the Board had already contracted a replacement CEO in secrecy before the dismissal of Bob Chapek, which implies the act was premeditated and thought through. However, when a company removes a CEO without a permanent replacement, it implies urgency in the removal, which also raises concerns about what news may unravel in the future.

The Board said it was time for new leadership and brushed it off. They also mentioned that it was not a result of any material or unexpected financial events. Highly suspicious. This puts the Board of Directors’ credibility on the line should negative news get unveiled. Its Q3 2023 earnings are expected to be released on Nov. 7, 2023.

If the company announces a new CEO with a strong pedigree beforehand, it can lift shares into the earnings report. It can also help to put in a bottom for the stock.

Analyst Downgrades

Many analysts chimed in on the CEO’s removal. On Sept. 15, 2023, TD Cowen cuts its rating to Market Perform from Outperform with a $55 price target. On Sept. 18, 2023, Jeffries cut its rating to a Hold from Buy and cut its price target significantly from $90 to $56. On Sept. 19, 2023, JP Morgan cut its rating from Overweight to Neutral and cut its price target from $70 to $52 per share.

Planet Fitness analyst ratings and price targets are at financehubusa. Planet Fitness peers and competitor stocks can be found with the financehubusa stock screener.

Daily Descending Triangle Breakdown

Shares attempted to break the descending trendline at $60.22 the day before the CEO removal announcement. Investors were in for a rude awakening the morning of Sept. 15, 2023, as shares collapsed over 15% on the announcement to $50.

Further analyst downgrades placed more selling pressure on PLNT, falling to a three-year low of $44.62 by Sept. 22, 2023. The daily relative strength index (RSI) is extremely oversold at the 19-band. Pullback supports from here are $42.06, $40.36, $37.56 and $36.41.

Block is a multiplatform ecosystem comprised of the digital wallet Cash app and payment processing platform Square. Square handles payment processing through various channels, including point-of-service (POS) and digital. It’s a legacy business that helped to democratize POS payments enabling small businesses and independent contractors to accept credit card payments without having to apply for a merchant account number from Visa Inc. (NYSE: V) and Mastercard Inc. (NYSE: MA).

Imprint Machines to Square Readers

In the old days, businesses needed to attain a merchant business account number through a lengthy application process to accept credit card payments. Businesses evolved from to POS credit card swipe terminals and machines. Square was one of the first to create a micro credit card swiper, Square Reader, that could be attached to a tablet or smartphone to swipe credit cards with magstripes. Fast forward to 2023, Square generates over 60% of Block’s total revenues.

I Quit

Stock Reaction

Block shares fell around 3% to $51.24 and 52-week lows on the announcement day. However, shares continued to fall another 15% in the following days. It’s worth noting that the markets have been in a sell-off on inflation fears and rate hike worries in the same period. Investors would have believed that having Jack Dorsey stepping in as Square’s interim CEO would have been good news, but market conditions spoke otherwise.

are at financehubusa. Block peers and competitor stocks can be found with the

Daily Descending Triangle Breakdown

The daily candlestick chart on SQ illustrates the descending triangle breakdown as shares tried to hold the flat-bottom horizontal trendline until its breakdown on Sept. 8, 2023. Shares could not bounce back through the flat-bottom and eventually collapsed further, accelerating the sell-off from the Sept. 18, 2023, news of the Square CEO’s departure out of the blue.

Weak macro market conditions kept selling pressure heavy on SQ as it made new 52-week lows. The daily RSI is extremely oversold at the 18-band. Pullback supports are at $42.33, $40.49, $38.01 and $36.11.

Before you consider Planet Fitness, you’ll want to hear this.

financehubusa keeps track of Wall Street’s top-rated and best performing research analysts and the stocks they recommend to their clients on a daily basis. financehubusa has identified the five stocks that top analysts are quietly whispering to their clients to buy now before the broader market catches on… and Planet Fitness wasn’t on the list.

While Planet Fitness currently has a “Moderate Buy” rating among analysts, top-rated analysts believe these five stocks are better buys.

View The Five Stocks Here

Share this article
Shareable URL
Prev Post

3 Oversold Household Names With Repetitive Strain Injuries

Next Post

Crypto Lobbyists in Washington D.C. Face Challenges After FTX CEO’s Meeting With Powell

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Read next
Key Factors Smartsheet is like Excel however with just a few added options that enable it to develop income and…
Key Factors Shares completed the week in search of path after a hotter-than-expected jobs report.  Subsequent…